Going Toe-to-Toe: Fusion vs. Arthroplasty for Hammertoe + Case study of digital Arthrodesis (Fusion) with Before and after pictures

Going Toe-to-Toe: Fusion vs. Arthroplasty for Hammertoe

Navigating the complex landscape of hammertoe treatment, patients are often presented with a pivotal choice between two leading surgical interventions: fusion, also known as arthrodesis, and arthroplasty. Each modality offers distinct advantages and considerations, making the decision process highly individualized. This detailed exploration aims to shed light on both treatments, equipping you with the knowledge to make an informed choice.

What is a Hammertoe?

Hammertoe is a common foot deformity that affects the alignment of one or more toes, causing them to bend at the middle joint and resemble a hammer or a claw. This condition often arises from an imbalance in the muscles, tendons, and ligaments that normally hold the toe straight. Over time, the persistent bending can lead to stiffness and pain, particularly when wearing shoes, as the toe's raised position leads to friction and pressure. Factors contributing to the development of hammertoe include genetics, arthritis, wearing ill-fitting shoes, and trauma. Recognizing the early signs of hammertoe is crucial for effective management and treatment, as the condition can become progressively worse, leading to significant discomfort and limitations in foot function.

Demystifying Hammertoe

Hammertoe manifests as a noticeable bend at the middle joint of the toe, causing it to adopt a downward curl rather than extending straight out. This condition frequently stems from an imbalance in the muscular and tendon structures of the foot, leading to sustained pressure on the toe's tendons and joints. As the condition progresses, the toe's abnormal posture becomes more pronounced, often resulting in significant discomfort, pain, and challenges in mobility.

The Fusion Solution: Arthrodesis Explained

Arthrodesis stands out as a definitive solution for advanced hammertoe cases, entailing the surgical fusion of the joint to rectify the deformity. The procedure involves excising a segment of the affected joint and securing the adjacent bones into a corrected position using hardware such as pins or screws. While this method guarantees a permanent fix and significant stability, it does compromise the joint's natural flexibility, which may not align with the preferences or requirements of all patients.

Arthroplasty: Preserving Flexibility

Contrastingly, arthroplasty offers an alternative approach by excising the deformed part of the joint and, if necessary, incorporating an implant or modifying the remaining bone structure to realign and restore the toe's functionality. This technique is particularly valued for its ability to maintain a degree of the toe's inherent mobility, catering to patients who prioritize functional flexibility alongside corrective outcomes.

Evaluating Outcomes: Fusion vs. Arthroplasty

The choice between arthrodesis and arthroplasty hinges on a careful assessment of the patient's specific condition, lifestyle, and treatment objectives. Arthrodesis delivers a lasting solution with minimal risk of recurrence but at the cost of joint movement. Arthroplasty, while preserving movement, may not offer the same level of stability as fusion, making it a more suitable option for individuals who value flexibility.

The Role of Patient Education and Tailored Treatment

An essential aspect of hammertoe management is patient education, empowering individuals to make informed decisions regarding their treatment. Understanding the nuances of each surgical option, including the potential risks, recovery times, and long-term outcomes, is crucial. A personalized treatment plan, developed in collaboration with a skilled podiatrist, can significantly enhance the effectiveness of the chosen intervention and the overall patient experience.

Why Citi Footcare is the Best Choice for Hammertoe Treatment in New York City

At Citi Footcare, under the distinguished leadership of Dr. Emanuel Sergi, we pride ourselves on being at the vanguard of hammertoe treatment in the metropolitan landscape. Our clinic is celebrated for its individualized patient care approach, ensuring that treatment regimens are precisely tailored to align with each patient's unique needs and aspirations.

Our clinic is outfitted with cutting-edge podiatric technology, empowering us to provide the most advanced surgical options for hammertoe, encompassing both fusion and arthroplasty. Dr. Sergi's unparalleled expertise, combined with our team's in-depth understanding of foot biomechanics, positions us to achieve superior treatment outcomes, facilitating a swift and comfortable return to everyday activities for our patients.

Hammertoe Case study of digital Arthrodesis (Fusion) with Before and after pictures

Below are before and after pictures of a patient with severely painful, contracted hammertoes, bilaterally. We chose to perform a digital arthrodesis, fusion, of toes 2 and 3 in order to permanently fix the hammertoes such that they will not come back in the future. This patient underwent fusion of the second and third toes with tendon lengthening in order to bring the toes down.

Pre-op photos

Post-op photos

Final Thoughts and Next Steps

If you are grappling with the challenges of hammertoe, let Citi Footcare be your partner in navigating the path to recovery. Dr. Emanuel Sergi, along with our accomplished team of podiatrists, is dedicated to supporting you through every phase of the decision-making and treatment process.

We invite you to reach out and schedule a consultation to explore how we can tailor a treatment plan to your specific needs, ensuring a journey to recovery that is both effective and aligned with your lifestyle. Discover why Citi Footcare is the pinnacle of podiatric care in New York City.

Citi Footcare
122 East 42nd Street
Suite 2901
(E 42nd and Lexington Ave)
New York, NY 10168



Leave a Comment